Face Off

7 years ago by

There are few things I love more than a facial. Unfortunately I don’t have a) the time b) the money to get them as regularly as I should (which I’m told is once a month).
I thought it would be a fun Atelier experiment to test out some products that tout facial results at home. So that’s what a few of us did, each in the comfort of our own bathrooms, each donning our most luxurious bathrobe (ok not actually, but that’s how I like to imagine it happened).

Et voila – the results! Though it should be noted we each have different skin types (explained below), and are not doctors. So proceed (and take our advice!) with caution.

Emily, Drunk Elephant Babyfacial

My skin has gone from being mostly dry to a bit more combination. I would say dry around the scalp and nose and more oily on the chin and forehead. Also my pores are starting to get bigger, I’m noticing more blackheads (ew!) and now tend to get hormonal acne around my chin.

I wanted to try Babyfacial because I really like that Drunk Elephant only uses clean, non-toxic ingredients and the product is full of active ingredients that are meant to really improve skin texture and clarity. Also because I’m obsessed with their packaging. For the last month I’ve been doing this facial every Sunday night, leaving it on for a full 20 minutes. Okay, heads up, IT BURNS. But it only burns for a few minutes and then you kind of forget that it’s there. After rinsing it off with water, I apply oil, and am left with very soft skin that feels balanced and looks less red. And while it burns, it doesn’t actually irritate my skin – but it does leave me with a glow, so much so that people actually noticed and commented on!

Carie, Tata Harper Resurfacing Mask

My early 30s skin hasn’t totally found her groove yet, so seemingly heads out into the world in a variety of outfits each week, feeling like Miss Independent, proud to have so much influence over my general well being. Sometimes she accessorizes with tiny, colorless bumps, other days larger reddish mounds or, if I’m lucky, an extra swipe of shine, with a nice side of dry patch under my eyes, just for equal measure.

These days my skin is thirsty, so I drink loads of water, moisturize, and use minimal makeup. Nevertheless buildup persists. So I brought in the (natural) big guns with Tata Harper’s Resurfacing Mask, an exfoliating treatment that is said to reveal an “instant glow.” It’s so good that I’m hiding it from my boyfriend (who likes to test drive my beauty treatments just a little too much for my liking) and hoping it lasts me until summer. I use it once or twice a week and my skin is 100% happier for it. Smooth as a baby’s bum and moisture locked. Similar to how you look after a perfect day at the beach with the salt, sand and sun, leaves you with that perfect glow.

I also fully recommend you keep it in the fridge. It thickens and feels kind of like applying a lovely smelling jam to your face!

Tori, Sanitas Skincare Brightening Peel Pads

My skin falls somewhere between normal and oily and has a tendency to be moody. I typically try and use products that are paraben free, full of moisture, and gently cleanse. Nothing too harsh, otherwise my skin lashes out and treats me to 5-7 days of breakouts, hives, rashes…you know, the good stuff.

Until a month ago, I had an irrational fear of peels – fearing they’d have some sort of Hannibal affect on me. But I received a tip from a beauty-industry pro (a facialist at Silver Mirror) and followed her instruction to try these Sanitas Brightening Peel Pads, which are paraben free cotton pads doused in witch hazel and other beneficial acids. To my surprise there was no aggressive burning, just clean, moisturized skin. Using it twice a week ended up leaving my skin feeling a little dry, but I will definitely be using these pads once a week, followed by my favorite moisturizing oil!

Brittany, True Botanicals Resurfacing Moisture Mask

My skin is generally dry and a bit sensitive which is why I was a little nervous to try True Botanicals’ Resurfacing Moisture Mask. A few seconds after applying it, I felt a slight tingle, maybe even a burn. I wasn’t sure how my skin was going to handle it but I also know that the tingle means it’s working. Luckily, my skin survived and I didn’t come out on the other side looking like a tomato. I have to say, despite the tingle, I didn’t see any drastic results/changes in my skin after using the mask twice a week for about a month and a half, but I definitely felt like my face was a bit softer and brighter the day after I used it. Plus, it has an amazing jasmine scent that creates the illusion, if you close your eyes real tight, of a mini trip to the spa.

Pia, SK-II Radiance and Moisture Boosting Mask

I should preface by saying that my skin is very sensitive and I often have problems when I stray from my tried-and-true routine (shout out Cetaphil!). But given the opportunity, I was happy to try a fancy new product. And what is fancier than a mask made of Pitera, inspired by a visit to a Sake brewery in Japan? Nothing, I tell you. Enter SK-II’s Radiance and Moisture Boosting Mask, full of a specific type of yeast that speeds up the natural rejuvenation process of your skin.

I put on my favorite robe (hey Emily) and applied the mask which, as most masks do, made me feel refreshed and like I have my life together. It was a lovely experience…until I woke up in the morning to red, bumpy and irritated skin. I was upset yes, because of the reaction, but also because it meant that my days of trying luxurious products had come to an end, they’re not for me. This one is packed with so many fancy ingredients that are supposed to drastically change the appearance and quality of your skin that I’d be curious to hear how it works when regularly used by someone with hardier skin! Let me live vicariously through you.

Shop the story


Add yours
  • submareen May, 11 2017, 12:35 / Reply

    Just a short comment about a technical issue:
    I have noticed lately (since the change to “Atelier Doré” I think), that the first image – or in other words – the picture related to the last post published is far too big to be seen with a smartphone (I’m using Iphone5S, there is no problem with the computer, I don’t know with a tablet). For example I only see 1/3 of the left part of this picture in height on my screen, then I have to scroll down for a while to read the title, it is anyway impossible to see the whole picture.
    Since I’m a huge fan and long-time reader of the blog, I hope that this comment can be helpful…
    And thank you for the amazing work all the team is doing!!

  • Natalie May, 17 2017, 1:46

    Hi! We have noticed this as an issue as well and are working to get it resolved as quickly was possible. Thank you so much for letting us know!! xx Natalie

  • Chartrand Frédérique May, 11 2017, 12:54 / Reply

    Moi je n’ai pas les moyens de me payer des cosmétiques ces temps-ci. Je fais donc des soins maison avec des produits naturels et ça marche vraiment super bien. Ma nouvelle découverte miraculeuse (j’ai une peau mixte avec quelques imperfections) : je prépare un masque avec du miel, du charbon végétal, du citron et de l’huile d’açai. C’est dingue comme ça fonctionne bien. Sinon je me fais des gommage en mélangeant du sucre et de l’huile de rosier muscat après un bain vapeur du visage à l’eau chaude avec une goutte d’huile essentielle de Tee Tree. :-)

  • laure May, 11 2017, 2:22

    Au quotidien, sur peau mixte et pour 3 sous, tu peux aussi utiliser l’huile de pépin de raisin ou l’huile de melon de kalahari :)

  • Mercedes May, 11 2017, 1:28 / Reply

    I am psyched to try the Tata Harper one. Gorgeous photo! X

  • The photo… It simply sweeps me off my feet.
    I keep gazing and gazing at it. It utterly overwhelms all of the senses, even though it is digital.
    So vibrant.
    Hugs from Warsaw,

  • J’ai mis la photo en fond d’ecran. :-)

  • Timina May, 13 2017, 8:17 / Reply

    That photo, so sweet and saturate of everything!

  • J’aime la photo, tellement incroyable!

  • poplab May, 17 2017, 7:27 / Reply

    Les soins maison c’est pas mal non plus. Une fois par semaine un bain vapeur Dr Haushka suivi du soin suivant le besoin mais en huile toujours: nigelle peau mixte ou rose de Welleda ou pepin de raisin+citron+miel non chauffé et safran (celui là c’est pour les grands jour mais c’est le meilleur)

  • Les soins et masques fait maison sont toujours préférées car c’est plus sûr, par contre je veux quand même essayer ces crèmes !

From the Archives

This or That
  • This or That
  • Holiday Gifting
  • Happy Holidays!
  • #AtelierDoreDoes
  • How To...
atelier dore this or that summer sandals chunky sandals vs. delicate sandals

This or That / Sandal Edition

This or That: American or Française?

This or That: American or Française?

atelier dore this or that lingerie lace or cotton sex month

This or That / Lingerie Edition

This or That / Blush vs. Bronzer

This or That / Blush vs. Bronzer

This or That: The Beanie

This or That: The Beanie

This or That: Nails

This or That: Nails

This or That

This or That

This Or That

This Or That

Silja Danielsen Photo

This Or That: Low Knot or Top Knot