A Love Letter To

Orange-y Red Lipsticks

6 years ago by

Orange-y Red Lipsticks

I’ve always been a collector. As a child I collected gold stars (the red flag of a perfectionist) and puffy stickers with equal aplomb so it makes sense that when I finally retired my sticker album and answered the keening siren call of the cosmetics counters that I’d develop a healthy hoarding habit.

Cut to today and my current abiding fixation with orange-y red lipsticks. They are my go-to answer for everything. If I’m feeling run-down a swipe of that technicolor gold across my lips leaves me feeling younger, prettier, cooler, more awake, and suddenly able to fit into that impossibly small pair of jeans I keep around just in case.

The color works all year round: it shines in the summer with a tan and it pops in the winter against pale skin. It makes me feel like the best version of myself, which for a little $25 tube is really something else. I might not have the funds to buy a ticket somewhere hot and beachy in the middle of February but I can definitely swing a tube of something pretty. The dangerous thing is that the instant gratification and low(er) price point always leaves me wanting more. I’m always wondering if there’s a better one out there—maybe a richer color or an impossibly matte formula that’s also creamy as all get out. Maybe the next one will make me feel really, really good about myself in a way that I never knew I could feel good about myself.

And then there’s this thing called the lipstick effect. A 2008 article in the New York Times talks about the fact that “after the terrorist attacks of 2001 deflated the economy, Mr. Lauder (as in Estée Lauder) noticed that his company was selling more lipstick than usual. He hypothesized that lipstick purchases are a way to gauge the economy. When it’s shaky, he said, sales increase as women boost their mood with inexpensive lipstick purchases instead of $500 slingbacks.” The only thing that makes more sense is sweatpants and Netflix.

Let me reiterate: I love makeup but I do not wear much of it. I’m the most unassuming lipstick junkie you’ll ever meet. I don’t love lipstick but I do love that wonderful orange-y red hue. I love it worn full-on, I love it blotted to nonexistence so it looks like I just ate the most glorious blood orange you’ve ever seen.

I can recall all of my favorites as quickly as a millenial can say “woke”. There’s the MAC one—that vanilla smell, that bullet-shaped casing (Lady Danger if you must know). There’s the one that got away, a Stila shade they discontinued, which I continued to keep scraping out with a bobby pin in a quiet, desperate frenzy until I hit rock bottom. I even saved some of the precious formula, taking it to a spot in Soho that caters to desperate people like me with promises of recreating your lost shade (two words: fake news).

My newest purchase was the happy byproduct of my long standing battle with winter— a shortcut through the Anthropologie in Chelsea Market found me fondling a tube of Pinch Cosmetics Matte Velvet Waterless Lipcolour in Poppy. That fondling led to the checkout line and it now serves as the keystone to my confidence (well, that and some mezcal).

Written by Lisa Pzystup

Art Direction by Jenny Wichman


Add yours
  • Love this!!! I read this article and thought it was all about me! I absolutely love lipstick and the red mattes are my favorite!! I actually collect almost every matte red from MAC, and ensure I get my hands on the limited ones. Other brands like Pat McGrath, Estée Lauder and Smashbox also have a few of my favourite red matte lipsticks. Just like you, I swipe on lipstick without makeup most days because it just makes everything better. Mascara and red matte lipstick days seriously beats all the work and day blues for me. I have over 250 lipsticks and hate when my friends and family judge me for my lipstick hoarding passion!

    What I’ve learnt through hoarding of red matte lipsticks, is once it’s the right texture and longevity I get a few others, because chances are they will be discontinued. I laughed at your bobby pin scraping of what’s left. I swear soon I’ll be doing this to 3 of my favorite Mac limited ones if I don’t cave to buying them off of eBay!

    BTW there’s more of us lipstick junkies out there! I wouldn’t consider us crazy at all. ??

  • I LOVE THIS !!

  • Rebecca May, 1 2018, 9:29 / Reply

    I have been wearing brights lately, and I put those down in 2012. I wore a lot of Revlon Moon Drops in Orange Flip—now discontinued.

  • Rouille May, 2 2018, 9:12 / Reply

    Aaaah j’adore! I’m a big fan of orange lipstick! And I KNOW the Stila one you’re talking about, I had it and I miss it ! Sephora produced one kind of similar, the chili pepper! I also love the Chili from MAC, did you ever try it? A beautiful brick mat !
    Bonne journée!

  • Lady danger for me too-all year round whenever I need to light up my face. I even got married in that orange-y perfection!!!
    y ?

  • Ai-Ch’ng August, 25 2018, 1:17 / Reply

    Can’t believe I’ve come to this orangey-red/reddish-orangey party so late!

    Your voice in this article is so entertaining and articulate and such a pleasure to read!

    My favourite lip attire are Ellis Faas’ pure orange lip colour (no name, just numbers… and mine fell off- but you can’t mistake that firework-orange colour on the sponge applicator); and Rituelle de Fille’s appropriately named, “Blood Orange”. Both are absolute joy in a tube.

    After applying straight from the tube by pressing them into my lips, I’ll always gently press my ring finger on the middle part of my lips at the very end, and dab that high and lightly on my cheeks and a little on my lids for an, “I-was-working-in-the-garden-bed-all-day, all week” kind of look.

    I didn’t find these until just this year, almost twenty years after commencing wearing lipstick (for my wedding day – a bright red by Poppy), and a very long and mostly unfruitful ;-) search for something so orange!

From the Archives

This or That
  • This or That
  • Holiday Gifting
  • Happy Holidays!
  • #AtelierDoreDoes
  • How To...
atelier dore this or that summer sandals chunky sandals vs. delicate sandals

This or That / Sandal Edition

This or That: American or Française?

This or That: American or Française?

atelier dore this or that lingerie lace or cotton sex month

This or That / Lingerie Edition

This or That / Blush vs. Bronzer

This or That / Blush vs. Bronzer

This or That: The Beanie

This or That: The Beanie

This or That: Nails

This or That: Nails

This or That

This or That

This Or That

This Or That

Silja Danielsen Photo

This Or That: Low Knot or Top Knot